This week, a couple I'm working with got an email from an agent they'd met at an open house. She had a unit she wanted to show them before it went on the market. She said it was heavily upgraded, the listing photos were old, and she'd love to take them through.
It sounded like a great opportunity, so they forwarded it to me, and I reached out to set up a showing.
Here's what I found out. There was no listing agreement and no off-market or coming soon agreement. She hadn't talked with the sellers about selling, and there was no price. When I asked about timing, the best she had was "maybe in the spring," and she admitted that conversation hadn't actually happened with the owners. The one thing she did have was that the sellers would let her in.
So the home was never really for sale.
The rules are clear
Sellers can choose to market their home privately, and sometimes that's the right call. But there are rules for it, and they aren't complicated.
The Realtor Code of Ethics says it plainly: Realtors "shall not offer for sale/lease or advertise property without authority." In Columbus, every private marketing option requires a signed listing agreement or disclosure from the seller.
In this case, none of that existed. No agreement, no authorization, no price. Just an agent offering to show a home the owners had never agreed to sell.
The questions nobody could answer
Think about what would have happened if my clients had walked in, loved it, and said "let's buy it." There's no agreement with the sellers, so nobody is authorized to sell it. There's no price. The owners might not even want to sell. And my clients had already told her they had an agent, so the only way this works is if their own agent is part of the process. If an agent offering a "private showing" doesn't want your agent involved, that tells you everything.
This is an attempt to steal clients
Let's call it what it is. In Ohio, a buyer has to sign a written agreement with an agent before they work together. This agent was told my clients were represented, so she knew there was an agreement in place. The goal was to get them in the door without me, win them over, and get them to leave their agent.
Why would an agent do this?
Because the odds are in their favor. Early in a search, the chance a buyer falls for any one house is pretty low, and lower still for buyers who aren't actively looking yet. The agent is betting you won't want to buy it. And if you do, the fallback is easy: the sellers name a price nobody would pay, and the "opportunity" quietly goes away.
Selling the house was never the point. Getting you in the door was.
It can even work on the sellers. An agent who brings buyers through a home that isn't on the market gets to look like a hero: "They loved your place so much, and it isn't even listed." Meanwhile the buyers came in believing the home was for sale. They never asked her to approach the owners and make something happen. It was presented to them as an opportunity that already existed.
The "secret inventory" pitch
Off-market access sounds impressive. "When's the last time your agent talked to you about off-market homes?" That pitch is meant to make your agent look like they're falling behind. In this case she was also pitching her group as the local experts for the area. But a secret listing that isn't actually for sale isn't adding anything. It's bait.
Why most homes sell publicly
Private sales are rare. In Zillow's national research covering 2023 to 2025, they made up less than 2% of the home sales analyzed.
There's a reason for that. Study after study, including major research from Zillow and Bright MLS, has found that private sales bring in less than homes listed publicly. Even sellers who start out private usually change course. One Bright MLS study found that nearly 90% of homes that began as private office exclusives moved to the open market before they sold. In my experience, sellers don't save much on the other end either, since agent fees and closing costs usually look about the same.
More exposure means more buyers, and more buyers usually means a better price. So when an agent leads with off-market opportunities, a healthy dose of suspicion is fair. More often than not, it's bait.
If you don't have an agent yet
You're the easiest target for this pitch. An agent talking about off-market opportunities can feel like an inside track. But if the home isn't actually for sale, there's nothing behind it.
Red flags to watch for
An agent leads with off-market listings.
Timing is vague and there's no price.
You hear "I can get you in" and get pushed toward one-on-one time.
A simple test
Whether you have an agent or not, say this: "I'd love to bring an agent to see it with me." If the opportunity is real, that's no problem. The listing agent will say, "Have them call me and we'll set it up." If their tune changes fast, or they suddenly say "never mind," you have your answer. In my experience, nine times out of ten that's what happens.
Who you want on your side
This is the part that matters most. This wasn't an agent saying, "This isn't for sale, but maybe we can talk to the owners." It was a home presented as coming up for sale, when it wasn't. If an agent is willing to bring you in under a false pretense, and have you drive across town for a home that was never for sale, just to win your business, ask yourself what else they'd be willing to mislead you about. Buying a home runs on trust. Work with someone who earns it from the very first conversation.