The 1902 clock tower in Uptown Plain City
Photo: Nheyob (Wikimedia Commons), CC BY-SA 3.0

Plain City Neighborhoods & Subdivisions

This page covers the Jonathan Alder Local School District around Plain City: the Village of Plain City, the nearby parts of Jerome Township and the rural townships that share the 43064 mailing address. Here are 16 neighborhoods and home types, sorted into three areas, with details on pricing, housing types and HOA status.

Median price
$482K
Neighborhoods on this page
16
High schools
1

Prices as of January through October 2026. Source: Columbus REALTORS MLS.

5101
Jerome Township to the north and east, the village in the middle, and rural acreage all around. Tap an area to jump to it.

Plain City neighborhood map

Tap an area to see its name and jump to it in the list.

The map is loading. All 16 neighborhoods are in the list.

  • Has a write-up in the list
  • Other mapped area

Plain City homes under $350,000

66 homes in the Plain City area sold for under $350,000 in the last two years, about 10% of all sales. 20 of them were manufactured homes in communities like Suburban Clearview, Green Meadows and Canaan Community, mostly under $125K. The other 46 sold from about $160K to $350K.

Where they cluster

Mostly older homes and ranches

22 of those 46 sales were homes built before 1970, mostly in Uptown. Most of the rest were ranch homes in Country Place and smaller plans in Madison Meadows. New construction in Plain City generally starts in the high $300Ks.

See what $350K buys around Columbus

Every neighborhood on this page is in Jonathan Alder Local Schools, which earned 4.5 stars overall on its latest Ohio School Report Card. The district has one high school, Jonathan Alder High School. Each card shows whether the neighborhood is inside the village or in a township. Always confirm school assignments for a specific address with the district, since some Plain City addresses are in other districts.

An aerial view of Plain City and the surrounding farmland
Photo: Pi.1415926535 (Wikimedia Commons), CC BY-SA 4.0

Jerome Township

5 neighborhoods

Unincorporated Jerome Township in Union County, north and east of the village, with Plain City mailing addresses. The older New California neighborhoods sit along New California Drive, and newer ones include Pioneer Crossing by Pulte and Mitchell Highlands by Rockford Homes.

Pioneer Crossing

$485K–$660K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HSJerome Township (Union County)

A Pulte Homes neighborhood built since 2024 on Bur Oak Drive, Wagon Trail Lane and Horseshoe Street, just outside the village in Jerome Township.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
2024–present
Lots
0.19–0.24 acres
HOA
Yes, about $105/mo incl. cable
Builders
Pulte Homes

New California Hills

$355K–$825K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HSJerome Township (Union County)

Homes built from the late 1990s to 2020 on New California Drive, Mission Drive and Corona Lane, many on larger lots.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
1999–2020
Lots
0.21–0.3 acres
HOA
Yes, about $50 to $100/yr

New California

$325K–$690K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HSJerome Township (Union County)

Ranches, split-levels and two-stories built from the mid 1970s to 2005 on Santa Barbara Drive, New California Drive, Mission Drive and Fresno Court.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
1975–2005
Lots
0.19–0.35 acres
HOA
Yes, about $60/yr

Mitchell Highlands

$565K–$800K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HSJerome Township (Union County)

A Rockford Homes neighborhood built since 2018 on Durham Court, Alnwick Loop and Camberly Avenue, among the higher price points on this page.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
2018–present
Lots
0.23–0.29 acres
HOA
Yes, about $470/yr
Builders
Rockford Homes

New California Woods

$455K–$890K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HSJerome Township (Union County)

Wooded lots on Carmel Drive, Malibu Court, New California Drive and Sequoia Court, with homes built from the late 1970s to the mid 2010s.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
1979–2015
Lots
0.5–0.8 acres
HOA
Yes, about $50/yr
The Farmers National Bank building on Main Street in Plain City
Photo: Nyttend (Wikimedia Commons), Public domain

Village of Plain City

10 neighborhoods

Inside the village limits, which cross the Madison and Union county line. Uptown has the oldest homes around Main Street, and the village has added several new neighborhoods since 2023, including Madison Meadows, Darby Station, Maren Reserve and the Run at Hofbauer Preserve.

Madison Meadows

$335K–$520K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HS

The biggest neighborhood on this page by sales, built by D.R. Horton from 2023 to 2025 on Darliene Drive, Madison Way and Leslie Drive. Ranch and two-story plans, with community cabanas.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
2023–2025
Lots
0.15–0.2 acres
HOA
Yes, about $140/quarter (varies by section)
Builders
D.R. Horton

Darby Station

$380K–$775K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HS

An M/I Homes neighborhood built since 2024 on Slippery Rail Drive, Interchange Drive, Speedliner Drive and Sand Dome Way. Homes on Aerotrain Court N carry a higher association fee.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
2024–present
Lots
0.15–0.2 acres
HOA
Yes, about $650/yr; about $2,950/yr on Aerotrain Court N
Builders
M/I Homes

Uptown Plain City

$225K–$540K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HS

Older homes in the original village, many built before 1960, on Main Street, Chillicothe Street, Gay Street and Central Avenue, close to the shops and the clock tower.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
Mostly 1900s–1960s
Lots
0.14–0.3 acres
HOA
No HOA

Maren Reserve

$360K–$615K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HS

An Arbor Homes neighborhood built since 2025 on Owens Way, Farmhouse Lane and Reserve Road.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
2025–present
Lots
about 0.14 acres
HOA
Yes, about $660/yr
Builders
Arbor Homes

The Run at Hofbauer Preserve

$440K–$590K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HS

A Rockford Homes neighborhood built since 2025 on Melody Loop, Ashby Way and Hofbauer Road.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
2025–present
Lots
about 0.17 acres
HOA
Yes, about $450/yr
Builders
Rockford Homes

Darby Fields

$450K–$535K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HS

Two-stories and ranches built from 2018 to 2020 on Ratcliff Lane, Alderwood Circle and Nighthawk Drive.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
2018–2020
Lots
about 0.17 acres
HOA
Yes, about $790/yr

Carriage Estates

$360K–$415K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HS

Homes built in the 1990s on Carriage Drive, Coachman Drive and Buckboard Lane. No HOA.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
1991–1997
Lots
about 0.23 acres
HOA
No HOA

Country Place

$310K–$380K

Ranch home

Jonathan Alder HS

Ranch homes built from 2001 to 2005 on Country Place Lane, Country Side Road and Country View Lane. The fee covers lawn care, snow removal, trash, water and sewer.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
2001–2005
HOA
Yes, about $300 to $350/mo incl. lawn, snow, trash, water, sewer

Copperfield

$370K–$655K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HS

Homes built from the late 1990s to the mid 2010s on Cooper Lane, Willow Creek Drive and Buckboard Lane.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
1998–2016
Lots
0.22–0.27 acres
HOA
Yes, about $180/yr

The Meadows

$420K–$470K

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HS

Two-stories built in the early 2000s on Wellsley Way and Weather Vane Way.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
2001–2004
Lots
about 0.2 acres
HOA
No HOA
The old Rosedale-Plain City Road bridge over Little Darby Creek
Photo: Nyttend (Wikimedia Commons), Public domain

Countryside

1 neighborhood

Homes on an acre or more outside any subdivision, spread across the farm country in Jerome, Darby, Canaan and Monroe townships.

Homes on Acreage

$245K–$1.47M

Single-family

Jonathan Alder HSVarious townships

Homes on an acre or more spread across Jerome, Darby, Canaan and Monroe townships, on roads like Crottinger Road, Converse Huff Road and Lafayette Plain City Road. Ages, sizes and prices vary widely, from small older ranches to newer custom homes.

Homes, lots and HOA
Built
Varies
Lots
1.5–5 acres
HOA
Mostly none

Plain City neighborhoods FAQ

What school district is Plain City in?
Most of Plain City is in Jonathan Alder Local Schools, which has one high school, Jonathan Alder High School. Every neighborhood on this page is in that district. Some homes with Plain City mailing addresses are in other districts, like Dublin City Schools, so confirm school assignments for a specific address with the district.
How much do homes cost in Plain City?
The median sale price in the Jonathan Alder district around Plain City was $482,500 for January through October 2026, based on Columbus REALTORS MLS closed sales. Older homes in Uptown start in the $200Ks, most of the new neighborhoods sell from the high $300Ks to the $600Ks, and homes on acreage can top $1M.
Is Plain City in Madison County or Union County?
Both. The Village of Plain City crosses the county line, with part of it in Madison County and part in Union County. The nearby township neighborhoods on this page, like Pioneer Crossing and New California, are in Jerome Township in Union County.
Where is new construction in Plain City?
The most active new-construction neighborhoods on this page are Darby Station by M/I Homes, Madison Meadows by D.R. Horton, Pioneer Crossing by Pulte Homes, Maren Reserve by Arbor Homes, and the Run at Hofbauer Preserve and Mitchell Highlands by Rockford Homes.
Do Plain City neighborhoods have HOA fees?
Uptown and older neighborhoods like Carriage Estates have no HOA, and most homes on acreage have none. Newer neighborhoods usually have one, often a few hundred dollars a year, and some cover extras like cable or lawn care.

Interested in a specific Plain City neighborhood?

I can provide a personalized market analysis with current listings, recent sales, and pricing trends for any Plain City neighborhood. Don't see the one you're looking for? Get in touch and I can send details on any Plain City-area community.

Kyle Snyder, Realtor with RE/MAX Partners in Dublin, Ohio

Let's Work Together

I'd love to hear about your real estate goals. Reach out anytime.

614-602-1090